November 2026
Our thanks as ever to Salisbury Library for allowing us to use their space for our meetings.
At the beginning of the report of the last Café meeting, we headed it by saying that because attendance, for unaccountable reasons, had dropped so much we might have to consider resting them until sometime next year. We are pleased to report a strong attendance yesterday and, as you’ll see, two lively debates took place so we shall be continuing as usual and our next meeting will be on Saturday 12th December.
The first topic was Why are things so bad in the UK and what can be done about it? This was posed by a new member recently returned from living in Toronto, now living in Portsmouth, who could not help notice the sense of national decline, how department stores have closed, more people were unemployed, drinking and what was termed ‘rough’ behaviours. He noted how eating out was very expensive in Britain
One explanation was the deliberate destruction (as was expressed) of social housing under Mrs Thatcher [where local authorities were not allowed to reinvest proceeds of sales into new houses].
Large parts of the industrial base were either sold off or allowed to collapse. The adherence to ‘crazy’ monetary policies following the neocon agenda was another factor. It was suggested that this was all possible because the discovery of North Sea oil enabling those receipts to be used for paying unemployment benefit rather than creating a Sovereign Wealth Fund as did Norway.
Floating the pound was another mistake it was argued because it led to wide fluctuations against dollar and other currencies which made life for exporters unpredictable.
Union power was too great it was argued although the level of restrictions probably went too far.
Another agreed with much of this and emphasised the failure of the new-liberal project. The fourteen years of a Conservative government which allowed the steady demise of public services was noted.
On the question of empty shops (which is not confined to Portsmouth) the role of the internet has clearly had an effect. Buy a book in Waterstones say, and they pay royalties to the writer, pay tax if they make a profit and and pay business rates. Buy a book from an on-line retailer and the transaction takes place off-shore somewhere, limited royalties are paid and almost no tax is paid either. Little wonder high streets are suffering. The internet has brought advantages it was stressed, we just needed to integrate it better into our society.
The problem was lack of regulation. Off-shore entities have no involvement in the community and more interested in dividends than investment.
Politicians came in for criticism and exhibited cowardice it was said. Big issues get kicked down the road and much of the time was spent ‘tweaking’ existing policies. Many are financially illiterate. Council tax was mentioned and houses have not been revalued since 1991. No politician is brave enough to carry out a revaluation after three and a half decades. In this connection it was noted that large numbers of powers have steadily been taken away from local authorities under both governments and centralised in Whitehall. They were also denuded of income under austerity.
It was pointed out that the only city where National Insurance contributions exceeded benefits was London. Elsewhere the opposite was the case. The inference being that without London, other parts of the kingdom would be even poorer than some of them already are.
Back to housing again and it was noted that in the ’60s say, mortgages were limited to 3 times earnings. Then controls were lifted and there was a house price boom. Providing incentives for new and young buyers was another mistake since that simply boosted demand and led to higher prices since levels of supply were largely unchanged. Both were examples of demand side changes without doing much about the supply side.
Change was often difficult because of the power of vested interests it was noted and in particular, the influence of the middle classes.
Globalisation was mentioned and how that has led in large measure to the decline of the manufacturing sector. Few firms can compete with the price of many Chinese or Far East produced goods particularly as in some cases forced labour was used. Linked to that is the mobility of capital. Goods and capital flow freely around the world but the movement of people is tightly restricted.
We touched on lobbying and CoP31 was in progress at present and it was revealed that there were more fossil fuel lobbyists present in Turkey than those arguing for more controls. It was an illustration of vested interests and their power.
The class system was mentioned and it was a pity the point was not developed. It was suggested that there has been a return to feudalism although some might reflect it has never gone away, only changed in form. It had been commented earlier that a very small number of people own most of the wealth of the world.
At the end, we had something of a synthesis. Why, it was asked is so much of our discussion about economics? One reason it had been suggested was the nature of cause and effect. The rise of Reform for instance arose out of issues of poverty, loss of jobs and general despair which fed into parties of that nature. Despite that, weren’t issues of community and fairness more important? Injustice was built into the system it was claimed, inheritance tax was an example: those with means are able to pass their wealth down thus enabling advantages to become normalised and entrenched.
We started by discussing the housing situation and the effects of right to buy. This policy derived from a shift of thinking from collective ownership to private ownership and with it the idea of individualism. Community issues took a back seat and privatisation promoted that trend still further. Our discussion was largely around the effects of those policies and the thinking which led to it. We discussed the diminished role of local authorities.
Toronto? The city, the largest in Canada, has a single layer of government and is able to decide on its priorities via a mayoral system. Maybe this is what gives it an advantage? Although Portsmouth is a Unitary and has been so since 1997, it does not have full funding powers by contrast.
The second debate was an abrupt change. Should Ukraine cede territory to Russia to achieve peace? Diplomacy was currently underway between various parties but principally the Americans and Russians. Success is not expected. The US negotiator Steve Witkoff is regarded by some commentators to be out of his depth.
The introducer of the topic thought Ukraine should not cede any territory to Russia. It would simply allow aggression to be rewarded. Another speaker thought there was no possibility of a treaty or at least one that would last.
We speak of Ukraine as a single entity but there is a tangled history to the country. The east has a large Russian speaking population. In the west there are Polish and Lithuanian speakers. America’s attempt at interference was noted. The young predominantly want to join the west and this was a factor in the Maidan revolution. One thought there will be a frozen border conclusion much like that between North and South Korea. The current conflict was a ‘meat grinder’ with losses of around 2,000 a week. However, it was suggested Russia will never agree to any treaty or ceasefire without the whole of the Donbas.
The role of the US was variously mentioned and its worldwide crusade against communism which has wreaked such havoc in South America. Without US support, Ukraine would fail quite quickly. We have to remember the Holomador when Stalin’s policy of removing food from the country led to mass starvation and this meant the Nazis were initially welcomed when they invaded. It was claimed the US did not want peace and a promising deal was scuppered by them.
Another suggested that any treaty would be broken. Russia was an authoritarian country with little need to heed public opinion. It was still selling oil to India and elsewhere and any kind of uprising was unlikely. Any treaty would be broken they thought. Ukraine should cede territory and join NATO it was suggested.
A key feature of the current situation – not just in Ukraine – was that it is not ‘diplomacy’ we are talking about but ‘Trump diplomacy’ which is quite different. It was about deals, cosying up to autocrats and personal and family enrichment. [Trump, Putin and Xi Jinping are to meet soon: terrifying thought]. This was having a major impact on the war. It must also be noted that Russia, far from being a pariah, was getting a lot of support from the rest of the world eg. Iran, China, India and North Korea. It was suggested that Ukraine will find it hard to hold out beyond two years more.
It was wondered whether we might get a more pro-Ukraine administration when Trump’s term expires.
We were reminded that it was once proposed that Russia join NATO. That did seem a long time ago.
Russian history was mentioned and the feelings the Russians have of inferiority. They were one of the last to shake off the monarchical system in 1917 and serfdom was only ended in 1861. There was a fear of being surrounded which does seem strange to us but the nation has massive land borders and has of course been invaded twice in recent history. The Russian economy was a failure it was noted with low per capita incomes.
Were other nations on Russia’s border feeling under threat it was asked? ‘Yes’ was the answer and only that day the prime minister of Estonia was interviewed on that very point and they do take their defence very seriously. They have memories of Soviet hegemony and are keen to maintain their independence. [After our meeting it was announced that Estonia is closing its three borders with Russia in two weeks because of sabotage activity].
Inconsistency in Western policy was noted. The West and America defended Kuwait following the attack by Sadam Hussein but were now less keen on defending Ukraine. We should defend borders and uphold the Westphalian system. The idea of a ‘rules based order’ introduced after the war was mentioned. It was suggested that was never on the cards as the US never wanted a pre-eminent UN. They emerged from the war the dominant power and were not going to give any of that away to the UN.
The recent programme on BBC Radio 4 about the year 1956, the Suez crisis and Hungary demonstrated that Britain and France had no regard to the rules based order when they invaded Egypt. There was the Hungarian uprising that same year which was brutally put down by USSR. Any idea therefore of a golden age is not realistic.
The Cuban missile crisis was briefly mentioned and it received considerable publicity at the time. What was not known was the stationing of missiles by the US in northern Turkey to which the USSR had responded.
it is perhaps not surprising we came to no conclusion. Might is pitted against right and neither looks likely to give way. Maybe simple exhaustion will win in the end rather than some hifalutin peace agreement which will never endure. Ukraine hangs on with uncertain support from the US which Europe is in no position to replace.
Two interesting debates and people felt they learned a lot from them. Both were examples of the role of history in what happens today: the effects of the neoliberal agenda in the UK and the long and tortured history of Ukraine and Russia going back to Tsarist times and beyond.
We shall be meeting again.
Peter Curbishley
Leave a Reply